Liturgy is for the converted: part 1

In a desire to reach out to the un-churched some Catholic parishes have dabbled with the ‘church growth’ movement and attempted to make parishes ‘seeker sensitive’. The desire to reach out to the un-churched is good but the idea of mega churching a Catholic parish is bizarre. Faithful parishioners, those most likely to help with an effort at evangelism are only going to be alienated and anyone attracted will likely not stick with it. This is only the most recent trend, the last 50 years has seen repeated failed attempts to modify and dumb down the liturgy in an attempt to make it ‘relevant’ to the ‘youth’ or the ‘man on the street’. Usually this takes the form of  low quality inferior sacro-pop music or other forms of entertainment being added to the Mass . These attempts ALWAYS FAIL and so will this new thing. Here are my thoughts on mega-churches, outreach and its relation to liturgy.

Mega-churches– I say mega but it includes small ones as well. What I’m talking about is the loud, glitzy evangelical type congregations who use flashy lights, projector screens, smoke machines, lots of marketing and rock bands punctuated with emotionalized uber simplistic preaching, and everywhere glitz, glitz, glitz…   ‘and remember to visit our café after the service for free Starbucks coffee’.

Depending on how important being ‘seeker sensitive’ is to the leadership the hard things about Christianity may never be mentioned. “Take up your cross and follow me”…… not so much.

A stereotype? Yes but reasonably accurate. The thing is, while I am generally opposed to this form of religion it does play a role. Many people who know nothing about Christianity start here, it’s similar to other secular experiences and for some people comfortable. It is in this setting that many people encounter Christ for the first time. They cannot stay here however, what they are fed is the spiritual equivalent of cotton candy. If one is to keep the faith long term one must move on. Let’s bust some myths right here. Many Catholics are under the impression that these Churches are very successful, and experiencing massive influxes of converts. Yes they are experiencing influxes, mostly of sheep from other flocks. The reality is that there are revolving doors on these churches and the majority of new people were already churchgoers of some sort or another. Additionally (and as a former evangelical I can say from experience) a good percentage of people who ‘get saved’ don’t stick with it long term.

So summarizing what’s under the glitz:

Good- Getting the lapsed and un-churched to hear about Jesus. Providing a start and temporary home for those who are wondering about this Jesus.

Not So Good-  Depth, substance, maturity and stability.

To be continued…..

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Liturgy is for the converted: part 1

  1. cpttom says:

    As usual, spot on. It is always painful for me, a cradle Catholic who grew up during the 70s “Spirit of Vatican II,” to see this stupidity recycled again and again. I wish I could—wait a sec, I have–tell those who push this stuff that it failed the first time and it will fail again. The supposed springtime of the “Spirit of Vatican II ™” resulted in a meteoritic drop in attendance, apathy, and apostasy. It’s like a repeating nightmare, that I keep hoping to wake up from. This kind of stuff is kryptonite to the Catholic faith, and is just plain lame.

    Those who get caught up in the numbers game, are notorious for ignoring Tradition as it doesn’t “fit” with their preconceived “solutions” so it is discounted. Or, better yet, they just accept the old saws about the “bad old days” of the pre-counsilor Church. What they completely miss is that Tradition and the praxis that comes with it has the benefit of the test of time and simplicity so people can understand the faith and therefore be nourished spiritual by it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s